This document summarizes the claims that circulated on social media during the youth protests in Tirana, Albania, on 13-15 October, what official sources say, what field verification found, and what remains unconfirmed.
1. Methodology
We followed posts (through Faktoje’s group) on monitored Instagram pages and WhatsApp groups linked to the protest. We also followed official statements from doctors at the Trauma Hospital, the Ministry of Health and the State Police, Faktoje’s direct contacts with students on the ground, and Faktoje’s own field observation at the buildings of Student City (“Qyteti Studenti”).
The most serious claims spread on social media (people intubated, in comas, dead or abducted) were not confirmed by doctors, the Ministry of Health or field verification.
This does not mean there was no violence. Videos document several serious episodes of police intervention. The police announced that they had suspended 5 officers.
Some claims were debunked (the deployment of the army, Serbian police, the abduction of three girls in Student City), while others remain unconfirmed (who damaged the student buildings, and the use of metal cables by police).
Claims reviewed
| Narrative | Date/time | Platform | Verdict | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 people intubated due to police violence (Trauma Hospital) | 13 Oct, 21:00 | Instagram pages and other platforms | False | Trauma doctors, Ministry of Health, MIA |
| Dead and in comas (a girl, a 16-year-old, a 17-year-old)1 | 13 Oct, 10:00 | Instagram (screenshots, comments) | False | Contradicted by official sources: the Ministry and doctors |
| The government deployed the army against students | 14 Oct | Online portals | False | Faktoje |
| Photo of City Hall “completely on fire” | 13 Oct, 20:00 | Meta | AI-generated | Faktoje |
| Foreign police officers mobilized to suppress the student protests | 15 Oct, afternoon | Instagram/Meta/online pages | False / AI-generated | State Police; Faktoje’s field verification found no such participation |
| Detained young people are held lying on the floor in police stations | 15 Oct, 22:30 | Instagram, Meta, spread by TV Kombëtare | Unproven | Disputed by the State Police |
| Metal cables used by police as batons can fracture skulls | 15 Oct | Online portal JOQ | Unclear | Disputed by the State Police |
| Death of a student from Tetova linked to police at the protest | 14 Oct | Instagram, WhatsApp, WhatsApp groups, later TV and social media | False | Faktoje |
| Unidentified persons abducted three girls in Student City | 15 Oct, 20:00 | Instagram, screenshots, WhatsApp, social media | False | Faktoje’s field verification |
| The perpetrators of the attacks on the Student City buildings were police officers and PS (Socialist Party) members | 15 Oct, 11:00 | Instagram, social media | Unconfirmed | The police say they are investigating; Faktoje’s field sources say the attackers were adolescents, but who pushed them to act cannot be verified |
| A girl abducted by civilians in an unmarked van | 15 Oct | Instagram, WhatsApp group, story, TV Kombëtare | Taken out of context | Disputed by the State Police |
2. Chronology: what happened
13 October: The protest led by high school and university students clashed with police, who went on to use tear gas. In the evening, some protesters broke one of the doors of the City Hall building and set the first floor on fire.
Claims about people intubated, in comas and dead began to circulate. In the late hours of the night of 13 October, doctors at the Trauma Hospital spoke publicly and the Ministry of Health gave its first report.
On the same day, after videos showing clashes between police and protesters, a series of claims spread on social media about people in critical condition, in comas, intubated, and even loss of life.
Late in the evening, the police suspended 5 officers after the case of the injured 19-year-old and opened a disciplinary investigation.
14 October: As the second day of the students’ protest in front of the Ministry of Education was announced, several portals and social media profiles published a video showing military vehicles moving through Tirana. The footage of military trucks was accompanied by the headline that “Edi Rama is bringing the army against the protesting students,” implying that the Armed Forces had been activated to suppress the protest. The claim spread rapidly, creating the perception that the government had taken extraordinary measures.
15 October: After the attack on the dormitories in Student City on 15 October, several claims spread on social media and WhatsApp, among them the abduction of three girls and the link between the attacks and young people from the PS. Faktoje’s field verification showed there were no abductions. The identity and motives of the perpetrators remain unconfirmed and under investigation, although field accounts indicate the attackers were adolescents. On the same day, the State Police publicly disputed the version of a girl abducted by civilians in a van.
3. How the narratives spread
From claim to alarm. Within hours on the first day of the protest, called by high school and university students, narratives emerged about students being intubated, then in comas, and finally dead. The sources were anonymous (“someone who knows the doctor”) or absent altogether, and comments declared the claim “100% confirmed” with no name and no proof.
From alarm to radical calls. Unconfirmed information began to feed allusions that the authorities were hiding the truth. A post that began with “If it’s true that someone has died” went on to call for a “fight for survival” and a “war of the state against the people.”
The chain of spread. News circulates mainly on Instagram and in WhatsApp groups, is then discussed on prime-time TV shows, and is picked up again by social media. In other cases it moves from protesters’ groups (Faktoje is currently monitoring 13 such pages) to WhatsApp. A concrete example was the evening of 15 October, when a girl was reported abducted by civilians in a van; panic was created before the State Police issued an official clarification.
Politicization. Some claims aimed to attribute the violence to a political side (e.g., that the protesters who damaged the Student City buildings were from the PS) or to a foreign state (Serbian or German police).
What remains unconfirmed
- The claim that the attackers of Student City were instigated by the PS and the police.
- The nature of the “metal rods.”
Sources
- Agjencia për Media dhe Informim (MIA), announcement on the intubation claim: https://www.instagram.com/p/Dece7zHEVGx/?hl=en
- Public statement by Trauma Hospital doctors, relayed by MIA: https://www.instagram.com/p/Dec1KoSCEvv/?hl=en
- State Police, statement on the Serbian police claim: https://www.facebook.com/policiashtetitshqiptar/posts/pfbid0Q2BaszhqNgaua9Xq6fgG6oDNyDmvnxb6svMdSuYCBnAtcHjRtHyN7firh5rhbëqgl
- Faktoje, analysis of the claims about the dead and intubated: https://faktoje.al/2-te-intubuar-1-ne-koma-16-vjecar-i-vdekur-si-u-perhapen-pretendimet-e-pakonfirmuara-pas-protestes/
- Faktoje, the army: https://faktoje.al/i-rreme-alarmi-per-nxjerrjen-e-ushtrise-kunder-studenteve/
- Faktoje, photo of City Hall: https://faktoje.al/kjo-foto-e-bashkise-ne-flake-eshte-gjeneruar-me-ai/
Author: Faktoje