Skip to main content Scroll Top

Publications

Deputy Head of Serbia’s Electoral Commission at Forum in Russia: “I Like the Transparency of the Russian Electoral Process”

This automatically translated article was originally published by Istinomer.

By Emir Kahrimanović

Marko Janković, Deputy Head of Serbia’s Republic Electoral Commission (RIK), was among the speakers and participants at the “Dialogue on Fakes” fact-checking forum held in Moscow on 22 September. Janković took part in a panel entitled “Electoral Sovereignty in the Digital Age: Taking Stock of the Duma Elections”. The panel examined the Russian elections and was part of a forum organised by a Russian fact-checking network modelled on the International Fact-Checking Network (IFCN).

Janković Praises Russia’s Electoral Process; Another Panel Participant Had Previously Met Vulin

Serbian representative Marko Janković praised the work of Russia’s Central Election Commission and local electoral commissions.

“I really liked the transparency of your electoral process. I also liked the electoral culture I saw here — there are a large number of press conferences and substantive debates. I can see openness,” he said.

Pavel Andreyev, from Russia’s Central Election Commission, also participated in the panel alongside Janković. In 2023, Andreyev was among the Russian election observers in Serbia who stated at the time that they had not witnessed any incidents and had not heard from other observers that any incidents had occurred during the elections.

CRTA, a Serbian election-monitoring organisation, said that those same elections could not be considered free and fair.

Sergei Perminov, a senator representing Russia’s Leningrad Region and a member of the United Russia party, also took part in the panel. Two days earlier, Perminov had met Aleksandar Vulin, who was in Russia as an international election observer.

Other participants in this part of the panel included Vladislav Davankov, Deputy Chairman of the Russian State Duma and a member of the New People party; Alexandre Guerreiro from Portugal, a corresponding member of the Institute of Political and Legal Sciences and an international observer at Russia’s 2026 Duma elections; and Areg Aghasaryan, head of the Centre for International Cooperation and Interaction.

The forum, and the panel in which Janković participated, focused on promoting the concept of “electoral sovereignty” at a time when no genuine opposition was taking part in the elections.

Yabloko, the only political party initially permitted to run in the elections that opposed Russia’s aggression against Ukraine, was ultimately barred from participating. Just 12 days after it had been registered, the Supreme Court banned it from running.

The European Union assessed that Russia’s parliamentary elections, held from 18 to 20 September, demonstrated “the continued and deepening erosion of democracy” in the country and took place in an increasingly authoritarian political environment.

The EU also criticised Russia for failing to invite observers from the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), saying that this had deprived Russian voters and institutions of the opportunity to obtain an impartial and independent assessment of the electoral process.

Other participants in the forum included Sergei Lavrov, Russia’s Foreign Minister; Andrey Kondrashov, Director General of TASS; Vladimir Tabak, President of the Global Fact-Checking Network (GFCN) and Director General of ANO Dialog and Dialog Regions; Ella Pamfilova, Chair of Russia’s Central Election Commission; Vu Viet Trang, Director General of the Vietnam News Agency (VNA); Mohammad Al-Mannai, Acting Director General of Kuwait’s state news agency KUNA; Nur-ul Afida Kamaludin, Director General of Malaysia’s BERNAMA news agency; Brazilian journalist and geopolitical analyst Pepe Escobar; political commentator and Rossiya 24 presenter Maria Petrashko; and Sergei Novikov, Head of the Presidential Administration’s Directorate for Public Projects.

Elections in Russia and “Cyberattacks”

Election observers in Russia described the proceedings, including those in the occupied parts of Ukraine, as a “farce”. United Russia, Putin’s party, ultimately won, according to Deutsche Welle, as reported by NIN.

Nikolai Rybakov, leader of Yabloko — which had initially been allowed to participate before being removed from the ballot — symbolically spoiled his ballot paper. He had previously called on party supporters to do the same.

Both Yabloko and the traditionally strong Communist Party complained that their observers had been prevented from monitoring voting at polling stations in hundreds of cases.

Furthermore, according to independent election observers, polling-station records in St Petersburg did not match the number of voters whose ballots had been recorded.

At several polling stations, footage allegedly showed pre-marked ballot papers being inserted into ballot boxes. The BBC’s Russian-language service reported that public-sector employees in provincial regions had been forced to vote.

On the final day of voting, problems were reported with Moscow’s electronic voting system. Ella Pamfilova, Chair of the Central Election Commission, said that the system in the capital had been targeted by cyberattacks. She did not identify those responsible.

Leonid Volkov, a former close associate of opposition politician Alexei Navalny, who died in prison in 2024, expressed doubts that the reported problems with the system for issuing paper ballots were accidental. He suggested they might have been deliberately caused to encourage more people to vote electronically. “Demand a paper ballot!” Volkov wrote on X.

The media environment is another problem affecting elections in Russia. According to a Reporters Without Borders report, Russia ranks 172nd out of 180 countries in the World Press Freedom Index. By comparison, Serbia ranks 104th.

The “Dialogue on Fake News” Forum: A Familiar Imitation

The “Dialogue on Fakes” forum officially presents itself as a global platform for discussing methods of combating disinformation and developing fact-checking technologies. The event is organised by the Global Fact-Checking Network, established by the Russian news agency TASS, together with the organisation Dialog Regions.

Founded in 2024, the Global Fact-Checking Network (GFCN) was conceived as a counterpart to the International Fact-Checking Network (IFCN), of which Istinomer is a member. Instead of transparency, the GFCN offers propaganda packaged as fact-checking.

Reporters Without Borders has also investigated the network. Lupa, a Brazilian fact-checking outlet, revealed that GFCN members travelled to Venezuela last year to “observe” local elections. In a country where the opposition boycotted the vote and Nicolás Maduro’s regime retained power without difficulty, fact-checkers from the Russian network published a series of articles describing election day as “peaceful and joyful”.

The same group of Russian “fact-checkers” claimed that cameras at Russian polling stations build trust in the process while guaranteeing privacy. Among the group’s many expressions of praise for Russia’s elections was criticism of “Western reporting”, which it described as biased.

“They keep repeating the same tired stories about manipulation and coercion. In reality, the atmosphere is extremely relaxed and pluralistic,” said Denis Rogatyuk from Mexico.

You can read more about who the fact-checkers are and who merely calls themselves “fact-checkers”, and about the difference between genuine fact-checkers and those who simply present themselves as such.

Elections
Serbia Western Balkans